Shopify vs Etsy: The Ultimate Showdown for Manufacturers!

Author Samuel Fitzgerald

Posted Mar 9, 2023

Reads 4.5K

Book on Shelf between Toy Retro TVs

Shopify vs Etsy, the big question that has caused anxiety for many manufacturers looking to sell their homemade products online. Making tough life decisions can feel like picking out expensive beans at the grocery store - fiber low and panic high. But fear not, because this medically observed phenomenon is essentially boiled down to making decisions.

For humble scaling manufacturers, choosing between these two platforms can be a big decision. Are you looking for a marketplace with an established customer base or a platform to build your own brand? Ado, let's begin the ultimate Shopify guide where you'll learn about smart inventory software and pro tips for success. Plus, get a free e-book to help make your shopping trip finishes with ease.

Choosing the Best Platform: Shopify or Etsy?

Compare Shopify and Etsy - which e-commerce platform is the best for your homemade products? The main difference is that Shopify is an online store manage products inventory payments, while Etsy is a marketplace that lets you sell your products. If you're looking to start an online business, let's delve deeper into these platforms to help you make the right decision.

Yellow Train

One pro tip when choosing between Shopify and Etsy is to consider how you want to manage your orders. Shopify offers order management software that helps businesses performance by keeping track of orders and ensuring on-time PS. On the other hand, with Etsy, everything is managed through their channel separately. This means that all orders come through Etsy, making it easier to keep track of sales.

Ultimately, it comes down to what you're selling and how much control you want over your online store. If you have a large inventory or want more customization options, then Shopify may be the better choice for you. However, if you prefer a simpler set-up and are happy with the features offered by Etsy, then this platform could be perfect for your homemade products.

Discover the Exciting Characteristics of Etsy's Top Features

If you're a small business owner who wants to start selling online but aren't ready to invest sweat equity into building and managing a full-blown online store, then setting up an Etsy store may be a good choice for you. Unlike Shopify, which is a standalone store, Etsy aggregates sellers on one site, originally intended for artists, creators, and makers of handmade goods and vintage items. Note that Etsy isn't just for vintage items. One-of-a-kind original items can also be sold on the platform.

Woman Jumping Wearing Green Backpack

One of Etsy's major draws is its huge existing customer base. In 2018, Etsy reported having 395 million buyers and 21 million active sellers. This makes it easier to attract customers to your online shop. Additionally, Etsy has built-in marketing tools that help you promote your products within the platform. You can also integrate third-party apps or use Etsy-specific marketing tactics found in the "Etsy Seller Handbook," a comprehensive guide that can answer virtually any question you may have about how to manage an Etsy account.

Another advantage of using an Etsy store is that it simplifies payment processing. Unlike Shopify, which allows users to accept payments through third-party payment processors like Stripe or PayPal that charge additional transaction fees, Etsy users can accept payments through "Etsy Payments," the platform's in-house payment processor that supports major forms of payments including credit/debit cards, PayPal, ACH payments, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. Using this feature means you don't have to take care of billing yourself; orders communicate directly with your online dashboard or the "Etsy app." Plus, once you receive payment confirmation from the buyer's end, all you need to do is print postage from your computer without leaving the platform!

Exploring the Key Attributes of Shopify's Main Offerings

Shopify and Etsy are powerful e-commerce platforms that allow small-business owners to build, manage, and promote their digital storefront. However, Shopify offers more features than Etsy. With 90 professionally designed templates to choose from, you can easily transfer your online store to a Shopify store and securely accept major credit and debit card payments with Shopify Payments. The platform's built-in payment processor powered by Stripe is easy to use, but if you prefer other options, there are over 100 third-party payment processors available.

Shopify's huge arsenal of store management features saves customers' personal and billing information for easy access during future purchases. You can integrate dropshipping apps to fulfill orders or click connect with fulfillment centers for access to powerful performance analytics. In addition, the platform offers robust customer relationship management (CRM) tools and marketing tools such as built-in SEO tips integration, social media profiles for blogging, customers discounts, gift cards, and more. Business owners find everything they need in the Shopify App Store where they can download thousands of upselling inventory management SEO tactics product reviews.

The Shopify POS is one of the best platforms in-house software that hardware enables business owners to process payments using their mobile devices. It also integrates with all other Shopify apps so you can manage your inventory and sales from anywhere. When comparing Shopify vs Etsy, it's clear that Shopify offers a wider range of features making it easier for users to get started quickly without having to learn complex coding skills or hire an expensive developer.

Discover the Magic of Etsy Pattern: A Comprehensive Guide

If you're considering where to start selling your products online, Etsy and Shopify are two popular options. While Shopify offers a more comprehensive e-commerce platform, Etsy offers sellers a standard marketplace with fewer restrictions. However, Etsy also has an attempt at its own e-commerce platform called Etsy Pattern.

Etsy Pattern allows sellers to create their own website with customizable features such as banner templates and a unique web address. On top of that, email alerts can be set up to send customers updates on their orders or if an item is back in stock. Additionally, buyers can purchase advertising credits to promote their shop within the platform.

The best part? You don't have to pay anything extra for these sales tools! As long as you have an active shop on Etsy, you can sign up for a free plan on Etsy Pattern and start customizing your online store today. So why not give it a try and see how it can help your business grow?

Explore the Unique Features of Etsy and Shopify

Wonderful Aling Aling Waterfall among lush greenery of Sambangan mountainous area on Bali Island

Distinct differences surface when comparing Etsy and Shopify. At a basic level, Shopify offers advanced functionality for inventory management and capabilities for online sales. While Etsy is primarily known for its marketplace of handmade and vintage items, it also offers tools for sellers to manage their inventory and increase sales. However, where Etsy truly shines is in its community-driven approach, with features such as seller support forums and the ability to collaborate with other sellers on team pages. Ultimately, the choice between Etsy and Shopify will depend on the specific needs of each individual seller.

1. What Shopify offers

Shopify is an online e-commerce site that offers a single interface for managing sales channels, credit card transactions, and face-to-face sales with Shopify POS. The platform provides users with easy integration to make smart business decisions through the use of basic info and specific time periods to analyze their e-commerce key performance indicators (KPIs) such as individual products sales channels average revenue, order currency discounts, and more. With Shopify, sellers can generate actionable business intelligence to determine customer lifetime value and identify areas for improvement in their product development process.

One of the most useful features of Shopify is the multifaceted Shopify sales dashboard that provides actionable insights for sellers right from the start. This helps them hit the ground running with their existing store or even buy an existing store on Shopify Exchange (image source: author). Pricing plans are based on monthly revenue and age of business type which makes it affordable for businesses of all sizes. For those who already have an existing online store, they can also integrate it into the Shopify Marketplace to expand their reach and increase sales. Overall, Shopify offers a comprehensive solution for anyone looking to start or grow an online business.

2. What Etsy offers

Etsy is an online marketplace that offers small businesses and sole proprietorships a platform to sell their products on a small scale without the need for a standalone website or physical storefront. It's like having a virtual craft fair with tables set up for each vendor. With the prominently displayed search bar, potential customers can easily find what they're looking for and potentially receive more exposure than they would at a physical event.

The website traffic Etsy receives is highly ranked, consistently ranking in the top 150 globally. The search bar is a powerful tool to drive traffic to product listings, and there's even an add-on option called Etsy Pattern that allows sellers to create their own e-commerce website using their Etsy storefront as the storefront image source author. Third-party applications can also be used to drive sales and provide sales reports. Etsy sticks to its roots of being a marketplace for handmade goods, vintage items, and craft supplies while providing uncluttered easy-to-read information through Etsy sales reports image source author. Overall, Etsy offers small businesses and sole proprietorships an excellent opportunity to showcase their products on a widely recognized platform with high website traffic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Etsy better than Shopify?

Etsy and Shopify cater to different types of sellers; Etsy is better for handmade and vintage items, while Shopify is better for businesses with a wider range of products. Ultimately, it depends on what you're selling and what your goals are.

Is Shopify safe and legit?

Yes, Shopify is a safe and legitimate e-commerce platform trusted by over one million businesses worldwide. It uses multiple layers of security to protect customer data, offers reliable payment options, and provides excellent customer support.

How does Shopify compare to Etsy?

Shopify is a platform that allows merchants to create their own online stores while Etsy is an online marketplace for handmade and vintage products. While both have different purposes, Shopify offers more customization options and control over your store, while Etsy provides a built-in audience and community.

What's better Shopify or Etsy?

Shopify is better for businesses that want to have their own website and brand, while Etsy is better for individuals who want to sell handmade or vintage items on a popular marketplace. Ultimately, the choice depends on your goals and whether you prefer a standalone online store or an established platform.

Samuel Fitzgerald

Samuel Fitzgerald

Writer at Chelmer Valve

View Samuel's Profile

Samuel Fitzgerald is a writer, speaker, and entrepreneur who has dedicated his life to helping people achieve their goals. With a passion for personal development and a deep understanding of human behavior, he has helped thousands of individuals and organizations around the world reach new heights of success. As an expert in leadership and team building, Samuel has worked with some of the most successful companies in the world to help them build stronger teams and achieve greater results.

View Samuel's Profile